Skip to main content

Are Monkeys Smarter Than Humans? New Study May Have Some Answers

 


Well, it seems that monkeys have been shown to be more adaptable than humans. Although a Planet of the Apes scenario still looks quite far-fetched, and our position as the planet's dominant species is still undisputed, it's an interesting study that reveals a lot about the way we think and do things.

Published in Nature's Scientific Reports, the study looks at the cognitive flexibility, meaning the mental ability to adapt to new ways of doing things, of humans compared to capuchin monkeys and rhesus macaques. By using a nonverbal computer task, participants were urged to follow one set of rules, which then changed midway during the study. How well the participants adapted to this change in rules provides tremendous insight.

Participants, which comprised of 60 humans, 22 capuchin monkeys, and 7 rhesus macaques, were tested on a common cognitive flexibility experiment called the Learned Strategy–Direct Strategy (LS–DS) task.

Participants had to learn to complete tasks in a certain order (in this case, selecting the striped square, followed by the dotted square, then the triangle) called the learned strategy as a baseline test. Successfully completing the task resulted in positive auditory stimuli, with an additional banana-flavored pellet treat for monkeys.

After learning this set of rules, the probe test allowed an additional solution, which wasn't revealed to the participants, to take an easier and more efficient shortcut (selecting the triangle immediately) called the direct strategy to receive the reward faster.

What makes this study differ from other research covering cognitive flexibility is, it's an optional-switch aspect. Instead of forcing a switch of rules onto participants, this study gives them the option to explore alternatives which can differ in difficulty and/or efficiency, much like how we do it in real life.

All 29 monkeys adapted to the direct strategy quickly, compared to a measly 39% of humans. In fact, around 70% of both capuchin monkeys and rhesus macaques used the shortcut the first time it was available, compared to only 2% of humans (many only started experimenting around halfway through the probe trials).

The results of the study put capuchin monkeys and rhesus macaques at the same level as chimpanzees and baboons with regards to better mental ability to adapt to new rules compared to humans.

This study demonstrates in humans what is called a cognitive set bias, the tendency to stick to familiar learned strategies even if these are more difficult or inefficient. This inflexibility could stem from a number of different things, but the researchers propose our environment and culture have a lot to do with it.

From an early age, many of us are taught using rote learning strategies, which value memorization and rule-following over experimentation and risk-taking, which could help enforce this bias towards preferring stability over variability, even if the potential rewards are greater.

Understanding the presence of this cognitive set bias allows us to overcome it and explore new and better ways of doing things.

SOURCE: https://www.sciencetimes.com/articles/24089/20191017/capuchin-rhesus-monkeys-show-better-cognitive-flexibility-humans.htm

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Graceful hunter of the skies: The Black-winged Kite, where elegance meets precision

The black-winged kite (Elanus caeruleus) is a small raptor known for its striking appearance, with predominantly white plumage and distinctive black wingtips. It's often observed hovering while hunting for small mammals and insects. The black-winged kite is found in various habitats, including grasslands, marshes, and agricultural areas across parts of Europe, Africa, Asia, and Australia. Its diet primarily consists of small mammals like rodents, along with insects and birds. These kites are known for their remarkable hovering ability, which they use to locate prey before descending rapidly to catch it. They have a graceful flight pattern and are easily recognizable by their contrasting black shoulder patches and wingtips against their otherwise white plumage. Black-winged kites are generally monogamous, forming pairs that collaborate in raising their chicks. Their nests are often built in trees or on tall structures, and they may also use old crow or raptor nests. These kites are ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Funny Moment between a Hawk and a Frog

  For my first Post of the Year 2024, here's a funny moment between a hawk and a frog as captured by bird photographer  Randy Wei.  "I was shooting in a local park and my original target was to get a photograph of a hooded merganser. All of a sudden, a red-shouldered hawk appeared and landed in the mud under the shade. Then I started to see this hidden frog appear and begin to slowly start hopping toward the water. As the frog hopped, the hawk just stared at it without much action. I fired as many shots as I possibly could of these two in frame without much thinking, and this one appeared as if they were walking together. Well, that’s the shot, I thought!" - Randy Wei Randy Wei ( @randy_simplelife ) got into bird photography back in 2014. During the day, he works as an industrial design director, but after work, he likes to walk into nature with his camera and lens. We came across this fun shot he took of a red-shouldered hawk and a frog and connected with him to learn mo...
16 comments
Read more

Coming Down to the water for a fish kill - An Osprey Tales

The Osprey (Pandion haliaetus) is a large raptor with a distinctive appearance, notable for its unique hunting behavior focused on catching fish. Also known as sea hawk or fish eagle, the osprey is found worldwide, inhabiting a range of environments near water bodies, including coastlines, lakes, and rivers. Ospreys have several adaptations that make them exceptional fish hunters. They have reversible outer toes, which help them grasp fish with a two-toed and two-toed back arrangement. Their keen eyesight enables them to spot fish from high above, and they can plunge into the water feet first to catch their prey. These birds often build large nests on elevated structures like poles or trees near water, using sticks and other materials. Ospreys are migratory, with some populations covering significant distances during their annual journeys. Conservation efforts, including habitat protection and nest-site management, contribute to maintaining healthy osprey populations. Ospreys are known...
Post a Comment
Read more